Most popular setting sprays work for most buyers, so the ranking is tight. ONE/SIZE On 'Til Dawn leads with 29 of 30 saying it makes their makeup last, and e.l.f. Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist matches it for a fraction of the price (25 of 26).
Updated . How we count
Share of buyers who stated an outcome for keeping makeup on. Ranked by the lower bound of a 90% confidence interval, so a product needs both a good share and enough reports to rank high.
Praise and complaints are the points buyers repeat most, shown as a share of each product's first-hand reports.
ONE/SIZE
Best for the most consistent results
Nearly every buyer who described its effect said it works. Price is the most common complaint (6%).
No repeated praise yet.
e.l.f.
Best for a budget
Matches the leaders on staying power. Buyers mention value (15%) and a fine mist.
Skindinavia
Works for nearly everyone who described it. Buyers also mention value (15%).
No repeated complaints yet.
Charlotte Tilbury
Best for melting powder into skin
Works for nearly everyone who described it. Some mention that it melts powder into the skin (6%).
L'Oréal Paris
Best for a drugstore budget
The drugstore option in the top five. Scent is the most common complaint (10%).
Urban Decay
The original long-wear spray, still working for most buyers here.
No repeated praise yet.
No repeated complaints yet.
NYX
Best for a matte finish on a budget
Buyers praise the value (14%).
No repeated complaints yet.
We scanned 9,772 comments and found first-hand reports in 177 public threads on r/Makeup, r/drugstoreMUA, r/MakeupAddiction, r/Sephora, r/MakeUpAddictionUK and r/beauty, posted between Jan 2022 and Oct 2026.
A report counts only when the commenter says they used the product themselves. Recommendations repeated from someone else, questions and jokes are left out. One person counts once per product.
An AI model labels each report against a fixed list of points, and we review the labels before publishing. We publish counts and links to the threads, never the comments themselves.
Buyers overwhelmingly say yes for the sprays on this page. Every one of the top seven worked for at least 88% of the buyers who described its effect.
e.l.f. Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist: 25 of 26 buyers said it made their makeup last, on par with sprays several times its price.
It works for most (27 of 33), but it collects more complaints about extra shine than the sprays ranked above it.
HiveTried earns a commission when you buy through "Check price on Amazon" buttons. It never changes the ranking: the order comes from buyer reports only.